Critical and historical thinking

Students test identity sources for bias by naming the maker, the date, the audience, the purpose, the evidence, and the standpoint, and they separate a historical fact from an interpretation when two narratives share the Indian Act of 1876.

Session outline

About 50 min one-to-one, or 60 min with a small group

  1. 1. Warm up (5 to 10 min): Ask the quick questions with notes closed.
  2. 2. Teach: Work through the lesson slides in order.
  3. 3. Coach practice: Use the student examples and try-it tasks.
  4. 4. Check: Finish with the outcome prompts below.

Warm-up questions

  • How do tutors decide whether a source is biased?Listen for: Check who made it and why. This sets up source testing.
  • What is the difference between a fact and an interpretation?Listen for: A fact can be checked; an interpretation explains meaning. Listen for this split.
  • Why does the date of a source matter?Listen for: It shows the context it came from. This sets up historical thinking.

What to check they understood

  • S.1

    Ask them to test an identity source for bias by naming the maker, date, audience, purpose, evidence and standpoint.

    A strong answer names each one for a specific source and explains how they affect trust.

  • S.2

    Ask them to separate a historical fact from an interpretation in a short passage.

    A strong answer quotes a checkable fact and an interpretation, and explains the difference.

Likely gaps from earlier grades

  • Students call any opinion bias. Ask what the maker gains.

Work through the class slides

1 / 7

Two voices on one sash

  • Museum label, 1970: "Métis sash. Voyageur costume from the fur trade."
  • Métis educator, 2024: "People wear this sash at gatherings. It is a living symbol of Métis peoplehood."
  • Each text has its own creator, year, audience, and purpose, so students read those before students decide what the sash means.
A bright red finger woven sash with a pattern of arrows is tied around the waist of a person wearing a blue checked shirt.

A sash worn at Fort Langley National Historic Site as part of fur trade dress. A museum label might describe it only as a costume from the past. Métis people today also wear the sash at gatherings as a sign of Nation and family. Two texts can describe the same object very differently.

Photo: Ceinture-fléchée-ftl by Themightyquill, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0