Students test identity sources for bias by naming the maker, the date, the audience, the purpose, the evidence, and the standpoint, and they separate a historical fact from an interpretation when two narratives share the Indian Act of 1876.
About 50 min one-to-one, or 60 min with a small group
1. Warm up (5 to 10 min): Ask the quick questions with notes closed.
2. Teach: Work through the lesson slides in order.
3. Coach practice: Use the student examples and try-it tasks.
4. Check: Finish with the outcome prompts below.
Warm-up questions
How do tutors decide whether a source is biased?Listen for: Check who made it and why. This sets up source testing.
What is the difference between a fact and an interpretation?Listen for: A fact can be checked; an interpretation explains meaning. Listen for this split.
Why does the date of a source matter?Listen for: It shows the context it came from. This sets up historical thinking.
What to check they understood
S.1
Ask them to test an identity source for bias by naming the maker, date, audience, purpose, evidence and standpoint.
A strong answer names each one for a specific source and explains how they affect trust.
S.2
Ask them to separate a historical fact from an interpretation in a short passage.
A strong answer quotes a checkable fact and an interpretation, and explains the difference.
Likely gaps from earlier grades
Students call any opinion bias. Ask what the maker gains.
Class slides
Work through the class slides
1 / 7
Two voices on one sash
Museum label, 1970: "Métis sash. Voyageur costume from the fur trade."
Métis educator, 2024: "People wear this sash at gatherings. It is a living symbol of Métis peoplehood."
Each text has its own creator, year, audience, and purpose, so students read those before students decide what the sash means.
A sash worn at Fort Langley National Historic Site as part of fur trade dress. A museum label might describe it only as a costume from the past. Métis people today also wear the sash at gatherings as a sign of Nation and family. Two texts can describe the same object very differently.