Evidence and character

Students set criteria for a believable retelling, check Priya's crawl against the scene, and ask whether her caution stays consistent when a second version adds a smashed shutter.

Open matching student lesson ↗︎
2.3.2a2.3.2b2.3.2c2.3.2d

Session outline

About 50 min one-to-one, or 60 min with a small group

  1. 1. Warm up (5 to 10 min): Ask the quick questions with notes closed.
  2. 2. Teach: Work through the lesson slides in order.
  3. 3. Coach practice: Use the student examples and try-it tasks.
  4. 4. Check: Finish with the outcome prompts below.

Warm-up questions

  • How do tutors know when a retelling of a story is accurate?Listen for: It matches the facts of the original. This sets up checking.
  • What makes a character believable?Listen for: Consistent actions and reasons. Listen for consistency.
  • If a new version of a story changes a key detail, how could that affect a character?Listen for: It may make their behaviour feel off. This sets up comparison.

What to check they understood

  • 2.3.2a

    Ask them to set a few checks for a believable retelling and apply them to Priya's crawl under the shutter.

    A strong answer names checks such as matching events, order and motive, and tests the retelling against the scene.

  • 2.3.2c

    Ask them to decide whether Priya's caution stays consistent when a second version adds a smashed shutter.

    A strong answer compares her behaviour in both versions, cites evidence, and judges whether the change fits her character.

Likely gaps from earlier grades

  • Students accept any retelling. Ask which detail matches the original.

Work through the class slides

1 / 6

Action and motive in conflict

  • Criteria for this retelling: events in the scene's order, a conflict with two pulls, and a motive students can point to.
  • The scene: Priya is closing the rink snack bar when its metal shutter sticks halfway down with the cash tray inside, and the side door locks at 9:15. She crawls under because a yank might snap the shutter, and she still gets the tray out before 9:15.
  • A rewrite says she smashes the shutter with the stick and the tray tumbles into the lot. It is more dramatic and it contradicts the crawl.
  • Plausibility of the original holds: a stuck metal shutter, a stick used as a gap, five minutes, a door that locks. The lot-tumble adds a crash the setting left unprepared.
Two versions of the shutter Two versions of the shutter Scene Priya crawls under the stuck shutter so the cash comes out and the metal stays still. Rewrite Priya smashes the shutter with the hockey stick and the tray flies into the lot. Break The smash cancels the motive the crawl was built to show.