Evaluating sources

Two texts can mention the same rule and still prove different things. The date, the writer’s job, and what is missing tell students what each one can support.

Session outline

About 45 min one-to-one, or 55 min with a small group

  1. 1. Warm up (5 to 10 min): Ask the quick questions with notes closed.
  2. 2. Teach: Work through the lesson slides in order.
  3. 3. Coach practice: Use the student examples and try-it tasks.
  4. 4. Check: Finish with the outcome prompts below.

Warm-up questions

  • How do tutors decide whether a website is trustworthy?Listen for: Author, date, purpose and evidence. Listen for checks they can name.
  • Why might a company website and a news article describe the same product differently?Listen for: Different purposes. This sets up writer's job.
  • What does an old date on a source tell tutors?Listen for: Facts may have changed. This sets up currency.

What to check they understood

  • 3.2.2

    Ask them to compare two texts that mention the same rule and explain what each can prove.

    A strong answer names the date, the writer's job and what is missing for each, and explains what each source can support.

  • 3.2.2

    Ask them to judge whether a source fits their inquiry question.

    A strong answer checks the source's relevance, date and author, and explains whether and how to use it.

Likely gaps from earlier grades

  • Students may trust any source that looks professional. Ask who wrote it and why.

Work through the class slides

1 / 6

Two sources with different purposes

  • Handbook, page 6. The school handbook, page 6, sets a rule for the lost-and-found: an owner describes a mark on a lost item before staff release it.
  • Undated post. An undated post says, “The rule is slow, so the office should drop it.”
  • Page 6 states the rule. The post shows a lean, a push toward dropping the rule.
What each text can prove The school handbook, page 6, tells staff that owners describe a mark before the item is released. / An undated post says, “The rule is slow, so the office should drop it.” / Page 6 states the rule. The post shows a lean, a push toward dropping the rule. What each text can prove Handbook, page 6 The school handbook, page 6, tells staff that owners describe a mark before the item is released. Undated post An undated post says, “The rule is slow, so the office should drop it.” Page 6 states the rule. The post shows a lean, a push toward dropping the rule.